Eaglecrest High School Lindsey lettered in cheer and track while attending Eaglecrest High School in Centennial, Colo. She earned all-conference honors all four years in the 100-meter hurdles and in the 400-meters in her sophomore and junior seasons. She was the Centennial League champion in the 100-meter hurdles in her senior season and was an all-state honorable mention for the same event. She was the captain of the track team in her junior and senior seasons and captain of the cheer team her senior year.
Personal Lindsey was born Jan. 30, 1991, to Gary and Joanna Keller. She has an older brother, Steve. She is a third-generation athlete as her father played basketball at the University of Nebraska Kearney and her grandfather played football at Fullerton Junior College.